Prealgebra · Lesson 4.8

Comparing Fractions

Solve this lesson →All lessons

Two climbers sit at 79 and 811 of the way up. Eight is more than seven, so the second climber looks ahead, but elevenths are thinner slivers than ninths, so that climber is stacking more pieces that are each smaller. Neither one obviously wins. This lesson gives you three ways to settle a comparison like that, rewriting over a common denominator, cross-multiplying, and leaning on landmarks like 12, along with a feel for which one is quickest on a given pair.

Problem
North crew: 58 of a path. East crew: 712. Rewrite over a common denominator, find which crew leads, then report the gap as a single fraction in simplest form.
Show a hint
  • A fraction only tells you "how many pieces" once you know the pieces are the same size. Eighths and twelfths are not, so find one denominator that both 8 and 12 divide into and rewrite each fraction with it. The smallest one that works is 24.
  • Scale each fraction to twenty-fourths. Multiply 58 by 33 to get 1524, and multiply 712 by 22 to get 1424. Now both are counts of the same twenty-fourths, so the bigger numerator is farther along. Subtract the smaller count from the larger to find the gap.
Show the full solution
Rewrite both over 24. 58=5×38×3=1524 and 712=7×212×2=1424, so the north crew leads with 15 pieces to 14. The gap is 15241424=124, already in simplest form. North is ahead by 1/24 of the path. Comparing 5 against 7 directly does not work, since an eighth of the path and a twelfth of the path are different lengths.
Same size cells, just count them 5/8 = 15/24 (15 cells) 7/12 = 14/24 (14 cells) 0 1 the gap = 1/24
Both fractions are laid on one bar sliced into 24 equal cells, so every cell is the same width and comparing turns into plain counting. Rebuilt over 24, the top strip is 58=1524 with 15 cells filled, and the bottom strip is 712=1424 with 14 filled. The cells line up exactly between the strips, so the longer shaded bar is simply the one with more cells, which makes 58 the larger. The single gold cell is the whole difference, 15241424=124, so 58 sits exactly one twenty-fourth past 712.
Problem
Compare 47 and 58 via the diagonal products 4×8 and 7×5. Which is larger, and what is the gap in simplest form?
Show a hint
  • The two tops are 4×8=32 and 7×5=35. The larger top wins, because both pieces are now measured in the same 56ths. Which fraction does the bigger top belong to?
  • You have 3256 and 3556. The gap is just the difference of the tops over 56, so compute 353256 and then reduce.
Show the full solution
Over the shared bottom 56, 47=4×856=3256 and 58=7×556=3556. Since 35>32, 58 is larger, and the gap is 35563256=356, already in simplest form. So the gap is 3/56. Those two tops are exactly the diagonal products, which is why the diagonals settle the order without writing the common denominator at all.
Problem
Settle the wall: 79 vs 811. Compare 7×11 against 9×8. Which is higher, and by how much? Gap in simplest form.
Show a hint
  • Cross-multiplication sends each top across to the other bottom. Compare 7×11 with 9×8, and remember the bigger product belongs to the bigger fraction. That alone tells you which marker is higher.
  • Once you know 79 is higher, the gap is 79811. The common denominator is 9×11=99, so rewrite both fractions over 99 and subtract the numerators. Then check whether the result can be reduced.
Show the full solution
Cross-multiply. 7×11=77 belongs to 79 and 9×8=72 belongs to 811, so 79 is higher. Those products are the numerators over 9×11=99, so the gap is 77997299=599. Since 99=9×11 shares nothing with 5, that is simplest form. The left marker beats the right by 5/99 of the route.
Problem
611 vs 613: same tops. Elevenths are fatter than thirteenths, so six fat slices win. Find the gap in simplest form.
Show a hint
  • When two fractions share the same top, the one with the smaller bottom is the larger fraction, because the pieces being counted are bigger. So compare 611 and 613 by their bottoms alone, then subtract the smaller from the larger.
  • To subtract, rewrite both over the same bottom 11×13=143. That turns 611 into 78143 and 613 into 66143. Now subtract the tops and check whether the result can be reduced.
Show the full solution
Both tops are 6, and an eleventh is a fatter piece than a thirteenth, so 611 is the larger share. For the gap use 11×13=143, where 611=78143 and 613=66143, so 7814366143=12143, already in simplest form. The lead is 12/143. The denominators alone settled the direction, and the common bottom was only needed to measure the gap.
Problem
Blue 415, red 310. Match tops to 12: 1245 vs 1240. Smaller bottom wins. Which share is larger, and by how much? Gap in simplest form.
Show a hint
  • You already have the matched-top forms 1245 and 1240. Same top, so smaller bottom wins. Which bottom is smaller, 45 or 40? That tells you the larger fraction. Once you know the order, the gap is just the larger fraction minus the smaller one.
  • The larger share is 310. To subtract 310415, find a common bottom for 10 and 15, which is 30. Rewrite both as thirtieths, then subtract the tops. Simplify if you can.
Show the full solution
With the tops matched, 415=1245 and 310=1240. Both hold 12 pieces, and cutting into 40 parts makes bigger pieces than cutting into 45, so the red ribbon 310 is the larger share. Over 30, 310=930 and 415=830, so the gap is 930830=130. Red leads by 1/30 of a roll. With matched tops the smaller denominator wins, the reverse of the matched-bottom rule.
Problem
Tank 1: 89 (missing 19). Tank 2: 1112 (missing 112). Smaller gap means fuller. Which is fuller, and by how much? Simplest form.
Show a hint
  • The empty space in the first tank is 19, and in the second it is 112. With the same numerator of 1, the fraction with the bigger bottom number is the smaller piece. So which tank has less empty room, and is therefore fuller?
  • The fuller tank is the 1112 one, since 112 of emptiness is less than 19. The gap in fill levels is exactly the difference between the two empty pieces, 19112. Rewrite both over a common bottom of 36 and subtract.
Show the full solution
Each tank is one piece short of full, 19 for the first and 112 for the second. A twelfth is a thinner sliver than a ninth, so tank 2 has less empty room and 1112>89. Both missing pieces are measured down from the same full mark, so the fill levels differ by 19112=436336=136. Tank 2 is fuller by 1/36 of a tank.
Measure the gap, not the fill8⁄911⁄12011⁄91⁄12smaller gap, fuller bar, so 11⁄12 wins
Both bars run to the same finish line at 1, so do not bother measuring the long full part. Measure the short empty part instead. The top bar is missing 19 and the bottom bar is missing only 112, and lined up against the finish line that thinner gap is plain to see. A ninth of the bar is wider than a twelfth of it, since cutting into more pieces makes each piece smaller. The bar with the smaller gap is the fuller one, so 1112 wins.
Problem
Bars 1314 and 1415: gaps 114 and 115. Smaller gap is closer to done. Report the gap between the two bars in simplest form.
Show a hint
  • A bar is further along when the piece still left to fill is smaller. Compare the leftover pieces 114 and 115 first, since two unit fractions are easy to rank by their denominators.
  • The distance between the two bars is exactly the distance between their leftover pieces, because both bars are measured down from the same finish line. So compute 114115. Over a common denominator of 210 that is 1521014210.
Show the full solution
The top bar has 114 left to fill and the bottom has 115. A fifteenth is the smaller piece, so the 1415 bar is closer to done. Both leftovers are measured down from the same finish line, so the distance between the bars is 114115=151414×15=1210. The bars are 1/210 apart. Subtracting the unit fractions this way makes the big denominator appear once, at the end, instead of at the start.
Problem
Six scores: 59,49,715,916,1120,817. Beat 12 when top > half bottom. How many qualify?
Show a hint
  • Take one score at a time. For 59, half of the bottom 9 is 92, which sits between 4 and 5. Is the top, 5, bigger than that halfway mark? If yes, the score beats 12. Do the same quick check for the other five.
  • For an odd bottom like 9, 15, or 17, the top must reach at least the next whole number above half. Half of 9 is 412, so the top needs to be 5 or more. For an even bottom like 16 or 20, just double the top and compare to the bottom. Mark each score win or lose, then count the wins.
Show the full solution
A score beats 12 when its top is more than half its bottom. 59 wins since 5>412. 49 loses. 715 loses since 7<712. 916 wins since 9>8. 1120 wins since 11>10. 817 loses since 8<812. That is 3 qualifying scores. Half of a whole split into b parts is b2 parts, so one comparison per score does the job with no common denominators.
Problem
Phone 1: 713. Phone 2: 920. Use 12 as landmark, confirm with cross-multiply. By how much is the more-charged phone ahead? Simplest form.
Show a hint
  • Twice 7 is 14, which clears 13, so 713 sits just above 12. Twice 9 is 18, which falls short of 20, so 920 sits just below 12. The one above half is the larger charge. For the exact gap you still need a common denominator.
  • The winner is 713. To subtract, put both over 13×20=260. That turns 713 into 140260 and 920 into 117260. Subtract the tops and check whether the result reduces.
Show the full solution
Twice 7 is 14, which clears 13, so 713 sits above half. Twice 9 is 18, short of 20, so 920 sits below half. Phone 1 is the more charged one. Cross-multiplying agrees, 7×20=140 against 9×13=117, and those are the numerators over 13×20=260, so the gap is 140260117260=23260. Since 23 is prime and 260=22×5×13, that is lowest terms. Phone 1 leads by 23/260.
Problem
Temperatures 35 and 58: both left of 0. Warmer is nearer 0. Which is the larger value, and how far apart are they? Positive fraction in simplest form.
Show a hint
  • Forget the signs for a moment and just compare the sizes 35 and 58. A common denominator of 40 lets you stack them up. Whichever size is bigger is the morning that dipped deeper below the baseline, and a deeper dip means a value farther from 0.
  • Rewrite both sizes over 40. You get 35=2440 and 58=2540, so 58 is the bigger size and 58 is the deeper, more negative reading. The larger value is the shallower one, 35. For the gap, subtract the two sizes, 25402440.
Show the full solution
Compare the sizes over 40. 35=2440 and 58=2540, so 58 dips deeper below 0 and 35 is the larger, warmer value. The distance between the readings is the same as the distance between the sizes, 25402440=140, already in simplest form. The two mornings are 1/40 of a degree apart. Below 0 the bigger size is the smaller value, so compare as positives and then flip the verdict.
Problem
Three runners are near the finish. Mara is missing 16 of the course and Priya is missing 112, so settle those two by the smaller missing piece. Dev is at 79, so place him with a cross-multiply. Order all three, then report the gap between the leader and the runner in last, in simplest form.
Show a hint
  • Handle Mara and Priya with the missing piece first. Mara still has 16 of the course to go and Priya has only 112 to go. A smaller piece left means more finished, so one of them is clearly ahead of the other. For Dev, compare 79 against the others with a cross-multiply rather than guessing.
  • Compare Dev to Mara by cross-multiplying 79 and 56. You get 7×6=42 on Dev's side and 5×9=45 on Mara's side, so 79<56. Together with the missing-piece result, the order from least to most is Dev, then Mara, then Priya. Now the gap you want is leader minus last, which is 111279. Rewrite both over 36 and subtract.
Show the full solution
Priya is 112 short of the finish and Mara is 16 short, and the smaller leftover means farther along, so Priya is ahead of Mara. For Dev, cross-multiply 79 against Mara's 56, giving 7×6=42 and 5×9=45, so Dev trails Mara and therefore Priya too. The order from least to most is Dev, Mara, Priya, so the gap from leader to last is 111279=33362836=536, already in simplest form. That is 5/36.
Problem
9899 misses 199, and 100101 misses 1101. Smaller missing piece is larger rate. Which rate wins, and what is the gap in simplest form?
Show a hint
  • Forget the giant denominators for a second. Which missing piece is smaller, 199 or 1101? Fewer equal parts means bigger parts, so 199 is the larger gap. The rate that is missing the larger gap is further from 1, and the rate missing the smaller gap is the winner.
  • The two rates differ by exactly the difference between their missing pieces, 1991101. Over the common denominator 99×101=9999, that is 1019999999999. Subtract the tops and check whether the result can be simplified.
Show the full solution
The rate 9899 is short by 199 and 100101 is short by 1101. The bigger miss belongs to 9899, so 100101 is the larger rate. The gap between the rates is the gap between the misses, 1991101=1019999999999=29999, and 9999=9×11×101 is odd, so that is lowest terms. The rates differ by 2/9999.

Practice these ideas

Practice
Rosa: 34 of her wall. Ben: 57 of his. Find the common denominator, compare, give the gap as a fraction in simplest form.
Show the solution
Since 4 and 7 share no factor, the shared denominator is 4×7=28. Rosa has 34=2128 and Ben has 57=2028, so Rosa has painted more, and the gap is 21282028=128, already in simplest form. Rosa leads by 1/28 of a wall.
Practice
Compare 811 and 710 by cross-multiplying. Which is larger, and how much greater is it? Report the gap as a fraction in simplest form.
Show the solution
The diagonal products are 8×10=80 for 811 and 11×7=77 for 710, so 811 is larger. Those same products are the numerators over 11×10=110, so the gap is 8011077110=3110, already in simplest form. The larger beats the smaller by 3/110.
Practice
Find k so that 6k=1520. Set diagonal products equal: 6×20=k×15. What is k?
Show the solution
Set the diagonal products equal, 6×20=k×15, so 120=15k and k=120÷15=8. Quick check, 68 and 1520 both reduce to 34.
Practice
Compare 815 and 813: same numerator, different denominators. Which is larger? Report how much more that person has as a fraction in simplest form.
Show the solution
Both tops are 8, and thirteenths are bigger pieces than fifteenths, so 813>815 and the person with the 13-strand ribbon has more. Over 15×13=195, 813=120195 and 815=104195, so the gap is 120195104195=16195. Since 16=2×2×2×2 and 195=3×5×13, that is already in simplest form, so the gap is 16/195.
Practice
635 and 940 each rewritten with numerator 18: 18105 vs 1880. Smaller bottom wins. Gap between them in simplest form?
Show the solution
Both matched forms have a top of 18, and 80 parts are bigger than 105 parts, so 1880>18105 and the second recipe, 940, uses more. Both 40 and 35 divide 280, so 940=63280 and 635=48280, and the gap is 6328048280=15280=356 after cancelling a 5. The second recipe uses 3/56 more of the jar.
Practice
Scores: 712, 511, 1019, 613, 917. Beat 12 when top > half the bottom. How many exceed 12?
Show the solution
Double the top and compare it with the bottom. 712 gives 14>12, a win. 511 gives 10<11, a loss. 1019 gives 20>19, a win. 613 gives 12<13, a loss. 917 gives 18>17, a win. That is 3 scores above 12. Doubling works because 12 is exactly the case where the top equals half the bottom.
Practice
Green trail checkpoint: 815. Orange: 716. Use 12 as a landmark to decide which is farther, then find the gap. Give your answer as a fraction in simplest form.
Show the solution
Twice 8 is 16, which clears 15, so 815>12. Twice 7 is 14, short of 16, so 716<12. Green is the farther checkpoint. For the gap use 15×16=240, where 815=128240 and 716=105240, so 128240105240=23240. Since 23 is prime and does not divide 240, the gap is 23/240.
Practice
Cup 1: 910 full (gap 110). Cup 2: 1011 full (gap 111). Smaller gap means fuller. Find the gap between fill levels in simplest form.
Show the solution
Cup 1 leaves 110 empty and cup 2 leaves 111. The bigger bottom makes the smaller piece, so cup 2 has less empty space and 1011 is the fuller one. Both gaps are measured down from the same brim, so the levels differ by 110111=1111010110=1110. The two levels are 1/110 of a cup apart.
Practice
Survey 1: missing 150. Survey 2: missing 151. Smaller missing piece is further along. Gap between completion fractions in simplest form?
Show the solution
Survey 1 is 150 short of done and survey 2 is 151 short. A fifty-first is the smaller leftover, so survey 2 is further along. Both leftovers are measured from the same finished whole, so the completion fractions differ by 150151=512550502550=12550, already in simplest form. Survey 2 leads by 1/2550.
Practice
Temperatures 59 and 47. Warmer is closer to 0. Which reading is warmer? Report how far apart the readings are as a positive fraction in simplest form.
Show the solution
Compare the sizes over 9×7=63. 59=3563 and 47=3663, so 47 is the bigger size, which puts 47 farther below 0 and makes 59 the warmer reading. The distance between them is the difference of the sizes, 36633563=163. The readings are 1/63 apart.
Practice
Four sprinters: 712, 58, 1118, 23. Use the fastest comparison tool for each pair. Write the single largest fraction in its original form.
Show the solution
All four denominators divide 72. Rewriting, 712=4272, 58=4572, 1118=4472, and 23=4872. The pieces are now the same size, so the biggest numerator wins. That is 48, which came from 2/3.
Practice
Sand: gains 34, loses 13. Find what remains, compare to 12. By how much does it differ from 12? Simplest form.
Show the solution
Over 12, the leftover sand is 3413=912412=512 of a scoop. Half a scoop is 612, so what remains is a little less than half, short by 612512=112. The sand misses the halfway mark by 1/12 of a scoop.
Practice
Maya: 1316 of her goal. Theo: 1720. Both past halfway, so use cross-multiplication. By what fraction, in simplest form, is the leader ahead?
Show the solution
Both 16 and 20 divide 80. Maya has 1316=6580 and Theo has 1720=6880, so Theo leads. The gap is 68806580=380, and since 80=2×2×2×2×5 has no factor of 3, that is already in simplest form. Theo is ahead by 3/80.
Practice
Mosaic 1: 123124 done (missing 1124). Mosaic 2: 199200 (missing 1200). Smaller missing piece wins. Report the gap in simplest form.
Show the solution
Each mosaic is one tile from done, 1124 missing for the first and 1200 for the second. The bigger denominator makes the smaller hole, so mosaic 2 is the more complete one. The completions differ by the difference of the holes. Here 124=4×31 and 200=8×25 share only a factor of 4, so the least common denominator is 124×2004=6200, and 11241200=506200316200=196200, lowest terms since 19 is prime. Mosaic 2 leads by 19/6200.